AI Blog Thumbnails: 4 Rejected Images and the Prompt Rules That Fixed Them

AI Blog Thumbnails: 4 Rejected Images and the Prompt Rules That Fixed Them

Hi there.
Every post on this blog has an AI-made thumbnail.
Not every first attempt made it.
Here are four images that failed my review and the prompt change that fixed each one.
The first three originals had text in a different language than this post, so I show them here as simple illustrations.

Rejected #1: the AI filled in words I never gave it

My first-ever thumbnail needed a notebook with a three-item checklist.
The checklist was supposed to show my three writing principles: fact-checking, citing sources, and labeling ads.
I asked for "a notebook with three checked items" and didn't spell out the items.

Illustration: a checklist filled with content nobody asked for

The design was good.
But in the original, the three items read roughly "fact check," "concise sentences," and "reader focus."
Two of those three were never my principles; the model invented them.

Fix: write out every word that should appear in the image.
If a list, label, or sign is in the picture, its exact text goes in the prompt.

A phone showing ChatGPT

Photo: Patrick Gamelkoorn on Pexels

Rejected #2: quotation marks became part of the art

On the second try, I put the headline in single quotes inside the prompt.
The model drew the quotes too.

Illustration: a headline with quotation marks drawn into the image

The checklist was right this time.
But the title now sits inside a pair of curly quotes, and the magnifier ended up awkwardly behind the book.

Fix: give text without quotation marks, and add one line at the end:
"Draw the text exactly as given, with no quotation marks and no added words."

Rejected #3: "keep everything else the same" wasn't enough

I liked the design of #1, so I asked to change only the checklist items.
I attached the original as a reference and said "keep everything else the same."

Illustration: the original design on the left, and the edited version with a gray texture, a gold magnifier, and no blue panel on the right

The checklist was finally correct.
But the white background turned into gray paper texture.
The blue panel on the right disappeared, and the magnifier turned gold with a light-blue handle.

Fix: list what must stay, item by item.
On the retry I wrote: white background, the sky-blue panel on the right, a magnifier with a yellow ring and a navy handle, flat style.

Illustration: the fixed version matches the original design

That version passed review and became my very first thumbnail.

Rejected #4: one extra period

This one came later, made with a different image tool.
The headline was supposed to read "The One Switch We Kept."
The image added a period at the end.

Rejected: the headline ends with a period nobody asked for

A period sounds trivial.
But it was text I didn't ask for, and my rule is that review fails on any text I didn't ask for.

Fix: say "no punctuation of any kind," not just "no quotation marks."

Fixed: same design, no period

The retry came back clean.

A phone with an AI chatbot next to an AI book

Photo: Sanket Mishra on Pexels

The prompt template I use now

Every thumbnail prompt now ends with the same pieces:

  • the exact words, line by line, with no quotes
  • what must stay the same, listed item by item, when editing an existing image
  • "no people, no logos" unless I want them
  • "Draw only this text exactly as given, with no punctuation and no added words"

If you're wondering which tool I use for which kind of image, I covered that in Which AI to Use for What.
And why every image gets checked before anything goes live is in AI Agent Approval.

Wrapping up

Four rejections, four small prompt changes.
None of them needed a better model, just more exact instructions.
The common thread: the model fills any gap you leave, so leave fewer gaps.

What's the strangest thing an AI image tool has added to your pictures?
Let me know in the comments.
Thanks for reading to the end.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Claude Code on Windows for Non-Developers: 6 Snags I Hit and How I Got Past Them

Day One With an AI Agent Team: 6 Things That Broke (and the Fixes)

Updating 20 Live Blogger Posts at Once Without Changing a Single URL